Skip to main content

6 Reasons Why Your SEO Agency is Losing Clients

5 mins read

06 May 2025

Two challenges that SEO agencies commonly face are acquiring new clients and keeping them. Research shows that even a 5% increase in customer retention rate can increase profit up to 95%. That is why keeping customers is so crucial. But what if you can’t? What are the reasons why some SEO agencies can’t retain their clients? Find out why here and get started on your new journey of retaining clients with ease.

img
Approach for Better Digital Strategy!
Let's Talk/Get a Quote

1. Expectations misaligned.

Failure to set realistic targets from the get-go - driving most clients away. In an attempt to entice clients, some agencies resort to promising their clients with results that they may fail to meet at the deadline. 

First things first - evaluate your client's goals: are you overpromising and underdelivering? Make sure to address these questions first to provide a feasible and viable SEO campaign plan for your client.

2. Failing to educate the client.

Clients are sometimes misinformed about the fundamentals of search engine optimisation and how it works - which can lead to unrealistic expectations for the agency to meet.

Inform the client about the campaign's progress on a regular basis and any updates or changes that may have occurred. Communicating with your client on a regular basis will also help to establish you as their go-to expert when they have any questions. They will also appreciate it is you inform them about any current industry trends that will have an impact on the campaign.

3. Lack of value for money.

Another thing with most clients is they want to see the value out of the SEO investment right away without knowing good SEO takes time to come to fruition.

One approach you can use with them is to agree on long-term goals - provided it matches their business goals. Demonstrate that your SEO efforts have a positive impact on revenue and conversions - not just rankings. 

4. Your clients have no idea how your agency works.

Don’t leave your clients guessing about how your agency works. You must consistently inform them about what’s going on and what the recent developments are for the project so far, don’t forget to inform them of recent wins as well.

It also helps if you send them reports about current progress, a summary of work, and any steps that will need to be taken moving forward. Creating roadmaps at the start of the contract also helps them view the direction of the entire project.

5. No visible results.

The results of the campaign might not reach your client's expectations - this could be caused by multiple facts including a downfall in performance. Here are a few things to keep in mind to ensure your output is enhanced:

  • Check the internal processes. Are your current methods and internal templates ready and working? If not, revise the steps and make sure those are the ones proven to deliver.
  • A solid management tool setup. Use these tools so you can oversee progress and execute SEO strategies properly at any scale.
  • Extensive training. Training your team and preparing them for the upcoming challenges in the SEO field can lead them to implement surefire SEO strategies across the board. Keep them abreast with the latest industry updates, and expose them to SEO basics and details.

6. The product isn’t ideal for SEO.

SEO has proven to be a viable source of revenue and traffic for businesses. However, keep in mind that not all businesses will find the results to be positive. The readiness of a company to adapt to SEO is also a factor in the success of future campaigns.

According to Sam Wright, founder of Blink, some SEO campaigns fail due to a variety of reasons, such as ‘lack of product-market fit, pricing, poor positioning or categorisation’.

 

This concludes that an SEO campaign failure isn’t entirely attributable to the agency’s performance. It is rather part of the industry’s movement as well.

You should now be considering how to improve your customer retention. Understanding the situation and finding effective solutions are two essential ways to ensure you develop a strong relationship with your clients.

The Elephant in the Boardroom team offers premium holistic and semantic SEO services for your business so that you can easily be discovered on Google by your hungriest prospective customers and clients. Visit www.elephantintheboardroom.com.au for more information.

Expect sharp insights on marketing, website design and development, data and AI solutions and more.

Related Posts

Categories

Tags

Subscribe to our newsletter

Grow your business with actionable digital marketing strategies. Subscribe now!

clients testimonials

See how we have made a difference

1

/

6

Peter Durning

Corp Centre

Candace is a pleasure to deal with! She understands how important the image of our business is and delivers results to ensure the said image is top notch!

Jose Alvarez

JYGA Group | Project Manager

We really liked the high standard of customer service we received from the moment we decided to get the project done. Great communication and the website looks like ten (not one) million dollars. We were really impressed with the attention to detail and can do attitude from the team at elephant in the boardroom. All the questions we asked were answered promptly and nothing was too difficult. The website looks fantastic and we will definitely recommend you to all our business partners.

Kiki Makrogiannis

CO-FOUNDER | TRADE MATCHER

Elephant didn't just build Trade Matcher a website, they built us a Directory that could facilitate us in achieving our business goal: "linking locals". The team are excellent! Knowledgable, creative, innovative, pro-active and sensative to urgency. Highly recommended.

Launce Kent

DIRECTOR | WEALTH EVOLUTION FINANCIAL PLANNING

We engaged Elephant in the Boardroom to design and develop a new landing page, then website for our company Wealth Evolution Financial Planning. The website was built quickly, to specifications and it exceeded our expectations. Elephant made themselves available throughout the build 24/7 and made the process simple. We are ecstatic with the results. We have recommended Elephant to many of our clients and will continue to do so.

MMSG

DIGITAL CHANNEL MANAGER

A truely professional company that will deliver as promised and beyond.

PETROTTERS

Founder

Elephant In The Boardroom has been nothing short of exceptional. Going above and beyond to ensure my business succeeds has really helped solidify the relationship between us. We will continue to work with them as our business grows. We would have no hesitation in recommending their work to our networks.

Jo Marcou

Next Millennium Group

Big thank you to Candace director of Elephant in the Boardroom for bringing our vision and branding to life! Your professionalism and attention to detail is second to none - you have truly exceeded our expectations. Above all you were an absolute pleasure to deal with no task being to big or small, regardless of time of day! I cannot recommend the fantastic team at Elephant In the Boardroom enough.

Dr Joe Donnoli

Inate Health

Elephant In The Boardroom have created for us a wonderful, interactive and easy to use website. They are an up and coming company that are keen to stamp their name in this very competitive market. I am certain that if my dealings with them are anything to go by they will certainly succeed. Thank you Adi and Candace and we all here at Mount Street Chiropractic Centre wish you all the success.

Nestor Sequera

SN Integrity | Technical Manager

Great work for the team at Elephant In The Boardroom. Great support and understanding customer needs. Well done.

let’s talk
let’s Connect

Got bold ideas?

Got a big vision? Let’s make it happen.

Your next chapter begins here. Let's connect and explore how we can design, build, and grow something extraordinary together. Book your free consultation.

You’ve made it this far and that’s no accident. If you’re looking to innovate, grow, or shift direction, everything starts with a simple conversation.